What Does it Mean to be a Gay Christian?

group picnic

Have you just swapped one closet for another?

Good question. It’s one I ponder from time to time, and particularly this past weekend, when I checked my calendar and realised I’d just been to my 21st wedding in three years. Four more are already booked.

I’ve been just about everything at a wedding: usher, drummer in the band, party starter on the dance floor, even emcee. A best man, but never the groom. I’ve often been publicly happy for my friends and privately sad for myself. As I chose which suit to wear to the next one, I’d wonder: have I come out of one closet only to walk into another?

Some background. Five years I came out, aged 23. I’m a pastor’s son; I grew up in faith, and I spent enough time (too much, honestly) praying the gay away. I felt ready to step out and live as a gay man and a Christian, and I still am both.

What I believe, and why

I spent years talking with my pastor about what the Bible says on same-sex marriage. The conclusion I reached then is the one I hold now. To be clear is to be kind, so here it is: I believe God does not call Christians of the same sex to marry. It’s not because God hates gay people (his Son dying for you, as he did for me, suggests quite the opposite). It’s because of how the Bible describes marriage. In Ephesians 5, Paul calls it a “mystery” that points to Christ and his church, two distinct partners who love each other. I believe marriage on earth is meant to mirror that: one man and one woman.

That has a cost, and I don’t say it lightly. I’ve chosen to stay single and celibate. Yet becoming comfortable with the theology was the key I needed to come out to friends and family. My faith is stronger, and my relationships are healthier and more honest. I’ve also learned a lot of grace for myself and for fellow Christians and LGBT brothers and sisters, who may be asking where they fit in all this marriage chat.

Looking through the glass closet

Back to the original question – I don’t blame anyone for wondering. I think the church has a poor recent track record of loving and honouring its LGBTQ and single believers, straight or otherwise. Many 18–30s groups and Christian Unions up and down the country can feel like spiritualised dating pools. Marriage is quietly treated as the next spiritual “level”, and relationships that aren’t marriage rarely get honouring words. “Singleness be damned, long live the nuclear family!” was the message I heard echoing round many a holy place.

So, I had left the closet of shame about my attraction, and yet I still felt on the outside. Being single wasn’t only about missing the wedding day or the M&S Dine in for Two mocking my dining table. It could feel like missing out on love itself, and on the one relationship that doesn’t need translation. No wonder someone might think God must hate them.

For most of my twenties, I felt I was looking through a glass closet (the gay Christian version of the glass ceiling? – you decide). I could see marriage and all its fabled fortunes clearly, but when I walked towards it, I bumped my head on an understanding of the Bible that wouldn’t budge.

Being gay wasn’t the hard part. The hard part was not seeing that God was opening a new vision for my life. Thank God for the curiosity to ask: “If God is so good, surely there’s more to life than feeling this bad about something I had no control over?”

Community, Commitment and Compassion

God brought me men and women already asking these questions, who follow Christ this way too, not from resignation but from joy.

Community. I spent my last four years in London serving at my church, from the worship band to, yes, all those weddings. I had the time and energy because I was single and chose to live this way. The grass (and the church) grows where you water it. When I moved out of London this year, the Holy Spirit prompted me to ask my church to “commit” to me and set up a gift registry for the move. Not marrying doesn’t mean I don’t need a hand setting up a new life. They responded, and many privately thanked me for starting a conversation about being a church that looks after its own, as the first Christians did in Acts 2. I have God to thank for them every day.

Outside the church, I found Living Out, a charity for Christians who hold the traditional view of sex and marriage and want to live it joyfully. Through them, I found True Freedom Trust and its “Barnabas” groups (named after the “son of encouragement”), where I could put down my shame and sense of otherness amongst fellow believers – a literal God-send.

Commitment. I’m learning to put a premium on friendship: turning up even when tired, staying up late for a needed chat, taking cake and tea from the local bakery round to new parents. I’ve also chosen vulnerability, including lovingly challenging my church leaders on how we speak about LGBTQ issues. There is no community without commitment.

Compassion. No more hiding, no more closets, but coming closer to others on the edges. That purpose lessens my desire to fill the gap with marriage (frankly, where would I find the time?). Marriage is a great gift, but singleness steered towards virtue is a high good too, and I’d love every church to be able to say how it supports and honours its single and LGBTQ members.

An invitation

I hope you’ll explore this for yourself, starting with Living Out and True Freedom Trust, and see if God will show you what he showed me: that there is so much more to life. I have tasted and seen that God is good. What used to feel like a closet now feels more like Narnia, with a freedom and imagination I once found hard to grasp. It’s what I wear most often, to weddings and every day: the freedom to choose Christ, just as he chose me, and chooses you, whatever door you’re standing behind.

Talk to a Christian

Want to talk? Whether you have questions or just need to share, our mentors are here to listen. Fill out the form below for a free, confidential conversation. We’re ordinary people ready to walk with you on your spiritual journey for as long as you’d like. Use a nickname if you prefer; we’ll be in touch soon

Enable javascript in your browser if this form does not load.

Talk to a Christian

If you think that talking with one of us might help, simply fill out the form below. We will contact you as soon as possible and will continue corresponding with you for as long as you want.

We are offering this service completely free of charge because that is what friends do. Know that any contact information you share will only be used to communicate with you in a safe and confidential manner and will never be shared with a third party.

Please feel free to use a nickname if you prefer to remain anonymous.